Ethical and health impacts of dietary supplements: Critical analysis

Author

Ms. Krishnan N, a Zen entrepreneur in her 60s, founded Nava's Zen at 58. With 22 years as a lecturer, including 13 years in the Curtin University of Technology Perth, Australia Degree Twinning Program, she is now a certified yoga instructor, coach, and counselor. Her expertise enriches her current work.

Abstract
This article examines the complex landscape of the dietary supplement market, highlighting the significant roles played by healthcare professionals and the ethical concerns that arise from their involvement. It explores the misleading marketing practices, particularly the use of "natural ingredients" claims, and the lack of transparency in labeling that poses risks to consumers.

The article underscores the need for stringent regulatory oversight to ensure the safety and efficacy of supplements. It advocates for consumer education on the potential long-term effects of supplement use and emphasizes the importance of holistic wellness practices, such as balanced diets, physical activities, and urban gardening, as sustainable health solutions.

The article calls for greater scrutiny of the qualifications and practices of those marketing supplements and stresses the role of regulatory bodies in verifying product claims. Through a critical evaluation of current trends and practices, the article aims to inform and empower consumers to make well-informed health decisions.

Introduction
The demand for dietary supplements has surged significantly in the 21st century, becoming a major market with diverse options available to consumers. This growth is evident in the array of supplements found in drugstores, pharmacies, and department stores, where the choice can be overwhelming for both specific health needs and general dietary inclusion. Historically, the supplement market was dominated by a few direct marketing or multi-level marketing (MLM) companies. However, the landscape has expanded remarkably, with numerous new brands emerging, including both domestic and international products that cater to a wide range of health requirements.

India's influence on the Malaysian supplement market is noteworthy, particularly with Ayurvedic products that cater to the Indian community. These products offer a comprehensive range of single and combined supplements designed to address various health concerns. The market's competitive nature is expected to intensify as more businesses enter the supplement industry, challenging existing companies and introducing innovative products.

Research Methodology
This article utilizes a qualitative research approach, drawing on personal communications and observations. The author's insights are informed by experience in MLM companies and interactions with individuals involved in the supplement industry. Data were collected through informal conversations, social media monitoring, and firsthand encounters with marketers and sellers, providing a narrative and descriptive analysis of current trends and practices in the supplement market.

This methodology aligns with Creswell's (2013) qualitative inquiry framework, emphasizing the importance of context and the lived experiences of individuals within the industry. The challenges of gathering detailed information from industry insiders who prefer to remain anonymous are acknowledged. Therefore, the article aims to present an informed perspective based on qualitative data rather than quantitative metrics, reflecting the complexities and dynamics of the supplement industry.

The Surge in Supplement Demand: Underlying Causes and Implications
In recent years, the demand for dietary supplements has surged, driven by a complex interplay of factors. This section explores the reasons behind the escalating popularity of supplements and the societal trends that underpin this phenomenon.

The Role of Stress in Modern Lifestyles
One of the primary contributors to the rising demand for supplements is stress. Stress has become a pervasive aspect of modern life, particularly in urban areas. The fast-paced lifestyle in cities, marked by long commutes, traffic congestion, and high job demands, has significantly deteriorated overall health. Urbanization has also brought these stressors to rural areas, exacerbating the problem.

Daily commutes, often characterized by prolonged hours in traffic, contribute to both physical and mental health issues. The necessity of owning a car for daily activities has turned commuting into a significant source of stress. Traffic jams not only extend travel times but also require constant alertness, further straining mental and physical health (Smith & Jones, 2022).

Career Demands and Health Implications
Modern careers demand high levels of commitment and output, with employees often working beyond standard hours to meet organizational expectations. This has led to a competitive work environment where individuals strive for promotions and financial incentives. The pressure to excel and the resultant long working hours leave little time for physical activities, such as exercise or yoga, leading to various health issues, including back pain, finger numbness, and mental fatigue (Williams, 2021).

Unhealthy Eating Habits
The fast-paced lifestyle has also contributed to unhealthy eating habits. Convenience foods, such as fast food and processed food, have become staples due to time constraints. Hawker food and takeout options, although convenient, often use low-quality ingredients to keep costs down. This includes oils, sauces, and vegetables of the cheapest quality, which may be detrimental to health (Johnson & Lee, 2020).

The Impact of Competitive Society
Society's competitive nature, driven by the pursuit of success and material wealth, has further exacerbated health issues. Individuals prioritize career and financial success over health, leading to neglect of well-being. The pressure to provide the best for one's family and to maintain a high standard of living has also contributed to deteriorating health, as people have little time to focus on their physical and mental well-being (Chen, 2019).

Health Issues Across Generations
The lifestyle of the 21st century has led to health issues not only among adults but also among younger generations. Unlike in the past, where health problems were primarily associated with old age, today's youth are experiencing similar issues due to modern lifestyle stresses. This has made supplements an attractive option for maintaining health or addressing health concerns that have emerged (Kumar, 2018).

The Convenience of Supplements
Initially, supplements were primarily used to address dietary imbalances or deficiencies on the recommendation of healthcare professionals. However, they have now become ubiquitous, with people using them not only for health reasons but also to follow trends or enhance their well-being. The convenience of taking supplements - whether by swallowing pills or mixing powders - has made them a popular choice in today’s fast-paced society (Patel, 2017).

The Competitive Market
The surge in demand for supplements has led to a highly competitive market. Direct sales and multi-level marketing models have proliferated, offering consumers a wide range of products. This competitive landscape includes both domestic and international brands, with some companies leveraging multi-level marketing to reach a broader audience (Smith, 2022).

The Role of Doctors in the Supplement Market
The rapid growth of the supplement market can be partly attributed to the involvement of doctors. Today, a notable number of doctors are at the forefront of recommending supplements, often instead of traditional medications. This trend is fueled by the perception that supplements are a safer and more natural alternative to pharmaceuticals. Some doctors openly promote supplements, even participating in multi-level marketing schemes to earn additional income (Larsen et al., 2017). This practice raises ethical concerns, as it blurs the line between medical advice and commercial interests.

Ethical Concerns and Doctor Endorsements
The endorsement of supplements by medical professionals can significantly influence consumer behavior. When doctors recommend slimming products or other health supplements, they lend credibility to these products, which can lead to increased sales. However, this endorsement often comes without sufficient evidence of the product's efficacy or safety (Barnes et al., 2019). There is also a troubling trend of doctors downplaying the importance of traditional medications in favor of supplements, which can mislead patients about their health care options (Smith & Atwood, 2018).

The Misleading "Natural Ingredients" Label
The claim that supplements are made from "natural ingredients" is a powerful marketing tool. Consumers often assume that these products are inherently safe and beneficial because they are derived from herbs, fruits, and vegetables. However, the processing methods and the actual content of these supplements are not always transparent. Natural ingredients, in their unprocessed form, do not have a long shelf life. For instance, fresh turmeric or lemongrass cannot last long without preservatives (Gupta & Reddy, 2020). Therefore, it is essential to scrutinize how these ingredients are processed and what additional substances are used to ensure their longevity.

Quality and Authenticity Concerns
The quality and authenticity of natural ingredients in supplements are significant concerns. Imported Ayurveda products, for example, are often repackaged and labeled by local importers, making it difficult to verify their true content (Joshi et al., 2021). The term "natural" can be misleading if the ingredients have been heavily processed or if synthetic additives are used to preserve them. Consumers need to be aware of these issues and critically evaluate the claims made by supplement manufacturers.

The Hidden Ingredients in Supplements
Some supplements do not disclose all their ingredients on the label. This lack of transparency can lead to health risks, as consumers may be unaware of potential allergens or harmful substances. The processing of natural ingredients to make them suitable for long-term storage often involves the use of preservatives and other chemicals, which may not be listed on the product label (Bailey et al., 2013). It is crucial for consumers to demand better labeling practices and more rigorous testing of supplements to ensure their safety and efficacy.

The Growing Dependence on Supplements
As the years progress, there is a noticeable trend of increased reliance on dietary supplements, reflecting society's desire for quick fixes to health problems. However, it is crucial to critically evaluate whether these supplements are genuine wellness solutions or merely temporary remedies. If supplements were truly as effective as some claims suggest, there would be a significant reduction in the need for medical professionals and traditional medications.

Despite the widespread use of supplements, the prevalence of health issues continues to rise, as evidenced by the increasing number of patients in medical centers and hospitals (Bailey et al., 2013). This trend persists even though the population growth alone does not account for the escalating health problems.

The Reality of Supplement Approval
A common belief is that all supplements on the market have undergone stringent testing and approval by relevant authorities. However, the truth behind these claims is often less clear. While marketing materials frequently assert that supplements have been approved by health ministries, the actual oversight and regulation of these products can vary significantly (Cohen, 2014). There have been instances where the purported safety and efficacy of supplements were later called into question, yet consumers continue to seek these products in hopes of finding solutions to their health issues (Holt et al., 2010).

The Future of Supplements and Medication
The current trajectory suggests a future where supplements may become more prominently prescribed by doctors, potentially even replacing some traditional medications. However, this shift raises questions about the qualifications of those promoting these products. Unlike the pharmaceutical industry, which requires stringent qualifications and rigorous training for its representatives, the supplement industry often relies on individuals with varying levels of expertise.

In multi-level marketing (MLM) and direct selling models, individuals without formal education or relevant qualifications can become 'experts' in marketing supplements after attending brief training sessions (Larsen et al., 2017). These individuals often provide compelling testimonials, persuading others to use supplements based on anecdotal evidence rather than scientific validation.

The Influence of Digital Marketing
The rise of digital marketing, particularly on social media platforms, has further amplified the promotion of supplements. Social media has become a hotspot for supplement advertising, with individuals actively promoting products and sharing testimonials that often highlight miraculous health improvements. This form of marketing can be incredibly persuasive, as live testimonials and personal stories create a sense of authenticity and urgency (Freeman et al., 2020). However, the overwhelming presence of supplement promotions on social media also raises concerns about the accuracy of the information being shared and the qualifications of those providing it.

Critical Evaluation and Consumer Awareness
The societal dependence on supplements, fueled by both traditional and digital marketing, underscores a critical need for consumer awareness and education. It is essential for individuals to question the claims made by supplement manufacturers and marketers, particularly regarding the content and approval status of these products.

The transparency of ingredient lists and the rigor of regulatory oversight are key factors that consumers should consider when evaluating supplements (Gupta & Reddy, 2020). Despite the compelling narratives presented on social media, a cautious and informed approach is necessary to make sound health decisions.

Recommendations for the Supplement Market
Regulatory Oversight and Verification
The relevant regulatory bodies play a crucial role in the supplement market. They are responsible for verifying which supplements are approved and ensuring these products have undergone the necessary tests and processes before being made available to consumers. Transparent communication about the approval process and the accuracy of claims made by supplement manufacturers is essential. Without stringent regulation and verification, it becomes challenging to educate consumers about what constitutes approved and safe supplements (Bailey et al., 2013).

Doctor Involvement and Ethical Practices
Doctors who recommend supplements should be scrutinized to ensure they are promoting products that have been verified by relevant authorities. This scrutiny helps maintain ethical standards in medical practice and prevents conflicts of interest where doctors might prioritize commercial gains over patient health. Establishing clear guidelines on the involvement of healthcare professionals in the supplement market is crucial to preserve the integrity of medical advice (Smith & Atwood, 2018).

Regulation of Supplement Sales
There should be specific qualifications and training requirements for individuals who sell supplements. Implementing mandatory courses and certifications ensures that those marketing these products possess adequate knowledge and understanding. This regulation helps protect consumers from misleading information and ensures they receive accurate and helpful advice regarding supplement use (Larsen et al., 2017).

Consumer Education on Supplement Use
Educating the public about the necessity and efficacy of supplements is vital. Consumers need to be aware of the potential long-term consequences of supplement use and understand how to interpret labels and marketing claims critically. Public health campaigns should focus on informing consumers about the actual benefits and limitations of supplements, guiding them towards making informed decisions (Barnes et al., 2019).

Emphasis on Diet and Holistic Wellness
A significant aspect of public health education should be the importance of a balanced diet and holistic wellness. Diet plays a fundamental role in health, and individuals should be encouraged to prioritize healthy eating habits over reliance on supplements. Public awareness campaigns should highlight the dangers of unhealthy eating and the false security that supplements can provide (Gupta & Reddy, 2020).

Promotion of Yoga and Physical Fitness
Encouraging the practice of yoga and other physical activities is essential for holistic health. Yoga offers numerous benefits for the body, mind, and soul, promoting overall wellness without the need for supplements. Public health initiatives should emphasize the advantages of engaging in regular physical activity, such as yoga, as a more sustainable and cost-effective approach to health (Khalsa & Cohen, 2022).

Urban Gardening for Health and Fitness
Promoting urban gardening can serve as both a physical activity and a means to grow chemical-free, nutritious food. Encouraging people to engage in urban gardening fosters a healthier lifestyle and provides access to fresh, pesticide-free produce. This practice not only supports physical fitness but also contributes to overall well-being and environmental sustainability (Joshi et al., 2021).

Conclusion
The supplement market's rapid expansion has introduced both opportunities and challenges. While supplements can play a role in supporting health, the market is fraught with ethical concerns, misleading marketing practices, and a lack of transparency. The involvement of doctors in promoting supplements, often driven by commercial interests, blurs the lines between medical advice and marketing. Regulatory bodies must rigorously enforce standards to ensure that supplements are safe, effective, and honestly marketed. Consumers need to be educated on interpreting supplement labels and understanding the potential long-term effects of these products.

Moreover, emphasizing holistic wellness practices such as balanced diets, regular physical activity, and mindfulness through yoga can provide more sustainable health benefits. Encouraging urban gardening can further support healthy living by providing access to fresh, chemical-free produce. By fostering awareness and critical evaluation of supplements, society can make informed decisions that prioritize long-term health and well-being.

References

Bailey, R. L., Gahche, J. J., Miller, P. E., Thomas, P. R., & Dwyer, J. T. (2013). Why US adults use dietary supplements. JAMA Internal Medicine, 173(5), 355-361. 

Barnes, K., Ball, L., Desbrow, B., Alsharairi, N., & Ahmed, F. (2019). Consumers' perceptions and experiences of complementary and alternative medicine. Nutrition & Dietetics, 76(1), 54-64. 

Chen, L. (2019). The impact of competitive society on individual health. Health Sociology Review, 28(2), 123-136. 

Cohen, P. A. (2014). Hazards of hindsight—monitoring the safety of nutritional supplements. New England Journal of Medicine, 370(14), 1277-1280. 

Freeman, B., Kelly, B., Baur, L., Chapman, K., Gill, T., King, L., & Chapman, S. (2020). Digital junk: food and beverage marketing on Facebook. American Journal of Public Health, 104(12), e56-e64. 

Gupta, S., & Reddy, V. R. (2020). An overview of the processing and storage of natural products in the supplement industry. Journal of Food Science and Technology, 57(2), 273-282. 

Holt, E. W., & Saliba, S. A. (2010). The hidden risks of dietary supplements. Consumer Reports on Health, 22(4), 1-7. 

Johnson, A., & Lee, S. (2020). Fast food consumption and health outcomes in urban populations. Journal of Urban Health, 97(4), 567-578. 

Joshi, S. R., Bhonde, R. R., & Shastri, V. P. (2021). Quality control and standardization of Ayurvedic medicines. Journal of Ayurveda and Integrative Medicine, 12(1), 1-9. 

Khalsa, S. B., & Cohen, L. (2022). The Principles and Practice of Yoga in Health Care. PLOS ONE, 17(3), e0258594. 

Kumar, S. (2018). Lifestyle changes and health issues among younger generations. Global Health Journal, 12(3), 345-360. 

Larsen, H., Schou, J. S., & Kristiansen, K. R. (2017). The role of healthcare professionals in the dietary supplement market. Scandinavian Journal of Public Health, 45(6), 642-650. 

Market growth and diversity of dietary supplements: Journal of Dietary Supplements. (2023). Current trends in the supplement market.

Patel, R. (2017). The convenience of dietary supplements in modern life. Nutrition Today, 52(1), 33-38. 

Patel, R. (2021). Ayurveda's impact on the global supplement market. Journal of Traditional Medicine, 10(2), 34-47. 

Smith, J. (2022). The rise of multi-level marketing in the health sector. Health Marketing Journal, 14(3), 45-58. 

Smith, J., & Jones, M. (2022). Traffic congestion and health: The modern urban challenge. Journal of Urban Studies, 59(1), 89-102. 

Smith, R., & Atwood, K. C. (2018). The ethics of promoting dietary supplements. Bioethics, 32(7), 410-419. 

Williams, R. (2021). Work stress and its implications on health. Occupational Health Journal, 45(2), 201-217.